The National Writing Project
A NATE grass-roots educational research project
  • Home
    • Privacy Policy
    • NWP Blog >
      • Weekly write 1
      • Weekly write 2
      • Weekly Write 3
      • Weekly write 4
      • Weekly write 5
      • Weekly write 6
      • Weekly write 7
      • Weekly write 8
      • Weekly write 9
      • Weekly write 10
      • Weekly Write 11
      • Weekly Write 12
      • Weekly Write 13
      • Weekly Write 14
      • Weekly Write 15
      • Weekly Write 16
      • Weekly write 17
    • NWP Gallery
    • How It Works
    • Background & Principles
    • Who's involved >
      • Morlette Lindsay
    • Find out more
    • Updates >
      • Directors' report 2015
      • Directors' report 2016
      • Directors' report 2017
      • Directors' report 2018
      • Group leaders' review 2017
  • Courses
    • 2016 Residential
    • Belsey Bridge Oct 2016
    • 2017 Residential
    • Texts used at 2017 residential
    • Tate Modern 16 Aug 2018
    • Whitechapel workshop
    • NWP 2019 writing retreat
    • 2018 Residential
    • Metaphoraging
  • Digested reads
    • John Dixon
    • Harold Rosen
    • Raymond Carver
    • Janet Emig
    • James Britton >
      • Britton Anthology
  • Research
    • Publications >
      • The Rights of the Writer
      • Making Room for Writing
      • 41 reasons why you should join a writing group
      • The benefits of freedom
      • In our own hands
      • What has writing ever done for us?
      • PowerPoint presentations
      • Diving into Writing
      • Folding paper, opening words
      • Book of the Project >
        • Free writing
        • Notes on publication
      • Harold Rosen lecture 27 June 2015
      • Writing spaces
      • Writing teachers
      • Symposium slides 17.11.2016
      • If we teach writing ...
      • TED talk 18 March 2017
      • TESS article 2017
      • Affordances
    • Poesis, literature and learning
    • 4 benefits of teachers' writing groups
    • Teacher Testimonies >
      • Teacher Testimony 2015
    • In defence of creative writing
    • 40 years of writing pedagogy
    • DIY classroom research
    • Recommended reading and links
  • In Your Classroom
    • NWP in the classroom
    • Writing ideas >
      • Using Shaun Tan's 'The Arrival' >
        • Developing ideas: Garth Nix
        • paper shapes
        • Using film
        • Using drama
        • Postcard conversations
        • 1a Gothic Underground >
          • 1b Gothic lexicon
          • 2a Gothic body-parts
          • 2b Gothic passages
          • 3 Gothic investigation
      • New ideas 2015 >
        • Only connect
        • Answer
        • Collections and connections
        • Sherlock extracts
        • Characters from names
        • Developing Characters
        • Flip books
        • Small books
        • Names (A) >
          • Naming stones >
            • Geological terms
            • Stones writing example
          • Names and images (D)
          • Names in lists (B)
          • Further reading (C)
          • Examples (E)
        • Collections
        • Colours >
          • Colour names
          • More colours
          • Colour poem
        • Door tags
      • Quick writes >
        • Slightly longer exercises >
          • The world's a zoo
          • Word starter
          • Metaphors
        • Longer structured exercises
        • Short texts for quick writes
      • Collaborative >
        • Wendell Berry
      • Memories
      • Responding >
        • Ideas to develop response partnership in classrooms
    • Writing journeys
    • Writing histories >
      • Snapshots
    • Writing Journals >
      • Prompts for writing journals
      • Advice on journals 2014
    • Examples of Writing >
      • Writing from photos
      • How NWP works
      • Teachers' writing and reflection
      • Isabel Palmer >
        • Nightlife
        • Poppies
      • MK NWP
      • Whodunit writing
      • Writing alongside
  • Get Involved
    • Visit a group
    • Join an NWP Writing Group
    • Start an NWP Writing Group
    • Write Together Online >
      • NWP Group Login
    • A month's writing challenge
  • Contact NWP
Digested Reads

Frank Smith

"As long as writing remains a natural and purposeful activity, made available without threat, then children will be willing to practice it and consequently will learn."
Frank Smith, 1983: Essays Into Literacy (80)


2: Frank Smith, 'Writing and the Writer', 1982

Smith advocates holistic experiences of writing rather than practising skills separately. He favours a focus on the learner rather than the teacher. He advises the teacher to facilitate pupils saying what they want, rather than instructing pupils to conform to pattern's of the teacher's devising.

"Writing is not learned in steps: there is no ladder of separate and incremental skills to be ascended." This is a cautionary reminder of the abuses to which some UK assessment systems are currently put.

Smith says that skills are best acquired when needs are identified, and when the messiness of composition is anticipated and allowed.

He is convinced that creativity and growth are inhibited by an over-eagerness to classify pupils (e.g. levels and sub-levels) and to demonstrate 'progress'. (In this way, the current appetite for measurement is counter-productive, holding back the very learning it claims to advance.) "A child who believes that the main purpose of writing is to get a grade and an evaluative comment from a teacher is clearly not likely to develop into an interested or particularly competent writer ... Tests are almost inevitably based on very poor theories of what writing and reading involve; they are constructed by people whose expertise is in test constructions, not in writing or reading." ( Michael Morpurgo and Michael Rosen made similar criticisms of the SATs, and in 'Words not Numbers', Myra Barrs disputes the validity of the assessment of writing not based on the normal conditions in which writing is undertaken.)

So after his critique, what does he positively advocate? I've got it down to four things for teachers to do:
  1. Create a stimulating and trusting language environment with plenty of opportunities for learners to learn from each other, interleaving all the following experiences: discussion, role-play, reading books and watching films, and reflection on writing.
  2. Show pupils what writing can do to flesh out their intentions (modelling stages of the writing process) and what writing can look like.
  3. Balance when we help, intervene and allow freedom.
  4. Arrange regular and purposeful reading and writing.

In a later publication, 1985, Frank Smith wrote:
"People who don't trust children to learn or teachers to teach will always expect a method to do the job."


    The National Writing Project UK is a research project supported by NATE,
the National Association for the Teaching of English. Contact NWP.
Picture
Picture